The Mystery of the “Déjà Vu” Phenomenon: A Brain Error Full of Meaning

© Andrea Piacquadio/Pexels

This strange familiarity that sometimes grips us when faced with an unprecedented situation has intrigued philosophers and scientists for centuries. We have all experienced that famous ” déjà-vu “, a feeling that is sometimes very disconcerting, and this one is not is not just a simple neurological curiosity; it is a revealing mechanism of our consciousness and the complexity of our relationship to time.

Despite the many theories, the exact causes of this phenomenon remained a bit mysterious; this was without counting on the work of Akira O'Connor, a researcher at the University of St. Andrews in Scotland, one of the rare specialists in ” déjà-vu “. These were published almost a year ago in the journal Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews.

The Mechanics of the Familiar: A Telltale Mistake

” déjà vu ” occurs when the brain regions responsible for recognition send out erroneous signals of familiarity. This momentary confusion causes a uncanny gap between our immediate perception and a feeling of recognition that our reason knows to be unfounded. This dissonance is not the sign of any pathology, quite the contrary: it is even synonymous with the performance of our brain.

As O'Connor points out, ” Déjà vu is a mechanism that corrects an error and prevents us from believing that we really remember something. The paradox is that, despite what looks like a memory error, déjà vu occurs when the brain is functioning at its best .” Our brain is thus stuck in its validation of an illusory memory as authentic. This is not a memory failure, but rather a temporary bug in our brain's recognition system.

Behind the scenes of the memory illusion

Virtual reality experiments have made it possible to dissect more precisely the workings of ” déjà vu “in O'Connor's study. The researchers immersed participants in virtual everyday environments—a bowling alley, a garden—before confronting them with new scenes sharing the same spatial architecture.

Result: Faced with these new settings with familiar resonances, the participants systematically reported this disturbing feeling of recognition without being able to identify its source. This experimental manipulation thus demonstrated how our cerebral organ can be misled by structural similarities, even when we are unable to recall the original experience that is supposed to cause this feeling of familiarity. One could almost say that the brain is in the grip of a micro-hallucination when this sensation occurs.

The evolutionary enigma of a constructive “error”

This phenomenon thus proves once again how complex our cognitive apparatus is, capable of both producing an illusion of recognition and of identifying it as such. A peculiarity, which in some people, takes on a certain magnitude, notably those suffering from dementia.

The frontal lobes (part of the brain involved in higher cognitive functions) can lose their capacity for verification, leading to a destabilizing multiplication of feelings of familiarity. This symptom can even delay diagnosis, as patients appear to recover their memories when they are actually suffering from a persistent illusion.

The most astonishing thing is that this brain “error” does not seem to serve any apparent evolutionary purpose, which is in complete contradiction with the theory of evolution. It simply reflects our propensity to seek meaning in every experience, even the most disconcerting. As O'Connor explains, we are fundamentally “meaning-making machines” perpetually searching for patterns and understanding in our environment. This search for meaning is fundamental to the human species and acts as the true driving force of our existence. /strong>.